New cars often skip the spare tire to save weight, improve fuel efficiency, and reduce costs. Instead, they offer options like run-flat tires or sealant kits for handling flats.
Over the last decade, drivers have noticed a curious change when they pop open the trunk of a new car: the once-standard spare tire is nowhere to be found. Where once lay a full-size or compact spare, now there’s often an empty space, or perhaps a tire repair kit, inflator, or even just a foam padding to reduce noise. This trend is not unique to luxury or economy cars—it’s widespread across brands and models. But why? What’s driving automakers to ditch the spare tire, and how does this impact drivers?
Here, we’ll explore the factors behind this shift, look at the advantages and downsides, and discuss what drivers should know about their options.
Contents
Why Are Car Manufacturers Eliminating the Spare Tire?
Car manufacturers are increasingly eliminating spare tires from new vehicles, a decision motivated by multiple factors. Here’s a closer look at why this shift is happening:
Weight Reduction and Fuel Efficiency
One of the leading reasons for eliminating spare tires is fuel efficiency. A typical full-size spare tire and wheel assembly can weigh around 30-50 pounds. In today’s fuel-conscious market, automakers are doing everything they can to reduce vehicle weight and, by extension, improve fuel economy. Eliminating the spare tire is one simple, cost-effective way to cut weight from the vehicle.
For every 100 pounds of weight removed, fuel efficiency can improve by about 1-2%. While that may seem minimal, it becomes significant when aggregated across all vehicles produced and driven on the roads. Cutting weight helps manufacturers meet stricter fuel efficiency and emissions standards without having to invest as heavily in more expensive technology or redesigns.
Increasing Popularity of Run-Flat Tires
Run-flat tires have gained popularity over the last two decades as an alternative to spare tires. These tires are specifically designed to continue supporting the vehicle even after being punctured, allowing drivers to travel a certain distance (usually around 50 miles) at reduced speeds until they can reach a service station. By equipping cars with run-flat tires, manufacturers eliminate the need for a spare and add trunk space and weight savings for the driver.
Run-flats aren’t without drawbacks—they tend to be more expensive, have a stiffer ride, and may wear out more quickly than traditional tires. However, for drivers in urban or suburban areas, the convenience of not needing to change a tire in an emergency can outweigh these negatives. Run-flat tires are becoming standard, particularly on certain luxury brands such as BMW, which equips most of its new cars with them.
Inclusion of Tire Repair Kits
To offer drivers some level of assurance without a spare tire, many manufacturers now include a tire repair kit, which usually consists of an inflator or sealant. These kits are lightweight, affordable, and allow drivers to temporarily fix small punctures to get to the nearest repair station.
Repair kits aren’t a universal solution. They work best on minor punctures in the tread area, but they’re ineffective against larger tears, sidewall damage, or blowouts. Despite these limitations, tire repair kits offer enough of a safety net to cover many common scenarios, while allowing automakers to save on space and weight.
Space Constraints in Smaller Cars and EVs
Modern vehicle designs are placing a premium on interior and cargo space, particularly in smaller cars, crossovers, and electric vehicles (EVs). A spare tire, especially a full-size one, can take up a significant portion of a compact vehicle’s trunk. By removing the spare, automakers can provide more usable space for storage, which is a major selling point for consumers.
Electric vehicles are particularly impacted by space constraints. In an EV, the floor may be packed with a battery pack, leaving no room for a spare tire well. Since battery range is also a major factor for EVs, the weight savings from eliminating the spare can have a direct impact on the vehicle’s range and performance.
Cost Reduction for Automakers
While it may seem minor, the cost of including a spare tire, jack, and associated tools does add up. As manufacturers aim to keep vehicle prices competitive, every cost-saving measure counts. The savings from not including a spare tire can be substantial when applied across thousands of vehicles. Some manufacturers even make the spare tire an optional extra, allowing drivers to pay if they feel more comfortable having a spare.
Downsides of No Spare Tire
Despite the justifications, the absence of a spare tire is not universally well-received. Many drivers express frustration over not having one in a pinch, especially in remote or rural areas. Here are a few of the most common complaints:
- Limited Solutions for Severe Tire Damage: Run-flat tires and repair kits work well for minor punctures, but they’re no match for blowouts, large punctures, or sidewall damage. In these situations, drivers have no choice but to call roadside assistance, which can be costly and time-consuming.
- Higher Maintenance Costs with Run-Flat Tires: Run-flat tires are often more expensive to replace and can wear out faster. Drivers accustomed to changing tires themselves also find that run-flats often require professional assistance.
- Unreliable Repair Kits: Tire repair kits have limited effectiveness and shelf life, as the sealant can harden or expire. Even if a driver has a kit, they may find it unreliable or ineffective in certain situations, requiring them to replace it periodically.
- Limited Replacement Options in Some Areas: While run-flat tires are increasingly common, they are still less readily available than traditional tires, particularly in rural areas or smaller tire shops. Drivers may find themselves stuck waiting for a specific type of tire to arrive or paying more to obtain it quickly.
Alternatives for Drivers
Given these downsides, drivers have several options if they prefer to have a spare tire for added peace of mind:
- Purchase an Aftermarket Spare Tire Kit: Many automakers or third-party companies offer spare tire kits as aftermarket accessories. These kits include a space-saver tire, jack, and lug wrench and can be stored in the trunk. Though they add weight, aftermarket spares provide an option for drivers who want one.
- Consider Roadside Assistance Plans: Many drivers without a spare tire choose to invest in a roadside assistance plan, such as those offered by AAA or through auto insurance providers. These services offer 24/7 support for flat tires and other roadside issues, providing added security, especially for long-distance drivers.
- Stay Prepared with a Portable Tire Inflator: A small, portable tire inflator can provide a temporary fix for low tire pressure issues, allowing drivers to reach a nearby service station.
- Invest in a Comprehensive Tire Repair Kit: More advanced tire repair kits include tools to handle slightly larger punctures, but drivers should still understand the limitations of any kit they purchase. These kits often have a learning curve, so practicing or understanding their use can help ensure effective roadside repair.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are some FAQs about do why no spare tire in new cars –
1. Can I add a spare tire to a car that doesn’t come with one?
Yes, many vehicles can be retrofitted with an aftermarket spare tire kit. These kits typically include a compact spare, jack, and lug wrench, but they do add weight and take up trunk space.
2. How effective are tire repair kits?
Tire repair kits work well for small punctures in the tread but aren’t effective for sidewall damage or large gashes. Repair kits are meant to be temporary solutions to get the car to a repair facility.
3. How far can I drive on a run-flat tire?
Run-flat tires typically allow you to drive around 50 miles at reduced speeds (under 50 mph), though this varies by manufacturer. Check your car’s manual for specifics.
4. Are run-flat tires more expensive to replace?
Yes, run-flat tires generally cost more than traditional tires and may also wear out faster, meaning replacement costs can be higher in the long term.
5. What should I do if I have a flat and no spare tire?
If you have a flat and no spare, options include using a repair kit, inflator, or calling for roadside assistance. It’s wise to have a backup plan, such as a roadside assistance subscription.
Conclusion
The absence of spare tires in new cars is driven by fuel efficiency demands, cost-cutting, the advent of run-flat tires, and space limitations, particularly in smaller cars and EVs. While it has benefits, it also presents challenges for drivers accustomed to the security of a spare tire. As a result, it’s wise for drivers to be informed about their specific vehicle’s setup and to consider aftermarket options or roadside assistance to mitigate the impact of this industry shift.
Whether for weight savings or efficiency, the disappearance of the spare tire is one more sign of the changing nature of automotive technology—and it’s essential that drivers keep up.